Every Town
Every Town has a dark side and in this podcast we bring you the most insane True Crime stories, many of which you've never even heard of. We give it to you straight with no fluff. Just scary true stories that will keep you up at night. Because the truth is, no matter how nice a community may appear on the surface, Every Town has a dark side.
Hosted by: Andrew Fitzgerald
👀 Watch This Episode On Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/scarymysteries
🎧 Our Other Podcast Scary Mysteries: https://open.spotify.com/show/3ZooEZMoZ421WdsOVJhVkT
👁 Check out our movie AN ANGRY BOY for FREE!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BvtlOlODQ8g&t=5238s
https://tubitv.com/movies/100029672/an-angry-boy
International & Other Ways To Watch: https://www.anangryboy.com/
💀 MERCH: https://scary-mysteries.teemill.com/
💀 Free 7 Day Trail on Exclusive Episodes, Podcasts & Perks! https://www.patreon.com/scarymysteries
👁 X: https://x.com/ScaryMysteries1
👁 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/andrew.fitzg
👁 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@andrewfitzgerald
👁 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/scarymysteriesofficial
🗣 Business Inquiries, questions and comments hit us up at scarymysteries1@gmail.com
51
10 Years of Fear! The Stalking Nightmare of BIL...
For years, too many years actually, the Wackers asked themselves the same questions over and over: "Who?", "How?", and most of all, "Why?". Because for nearly a decade, Bill and Dorothy Wacker, who were just a peaceful elderly couple living in small town Ohio, were the victims of constant and persistent harassment. Harassment that defied logic and only continued to escalate over the years.
26 min
52
Virginia’s Most Gruesome Urban Legend – The Tru...
He murdered, broken peoples car windows and threatened contless individuals who were just unlucky enough to have been in the wrong place at the wrong time. When you see this psychopath, you’ll know it right away.., it’s likley he’ll be carrying an axe. And he always dressed head to toe in a grown mans rabbit suit earning him the nickname The Bunnyman.
23 min
53
Their Hair Was Falling Out Days After a UFO Enc...
It was just after Christmas, December 29th of 1980 when 3 regular folks cruising through the small town of Dayton Texas ran into an unidentified object that would change their lives forever.
23 min
54
Caught on Tape: The Unsolved Abduction of Jenni...
The disappearance of Jennifer Kesse is a frustrating case because there’s so much evidence to point to exactly what happened, and yet, no one has ever been caught for the crime and Jennifer still remains missing. It’s a situation where an innocent young woman was just going about her daily routine when she crossed paths with someone who intended to do her harm and ever since then its been a nightmare for her family who just wants to know what happened and for justice to be served.
24 min
55
Mystery On The Rails: The Strange Case Of The B...
16 year old Don Henry and Kevin Ives who was 17 were best friends who did everything together and in the early hours of August 23, 1987, they also died together.
26 min
56
The Strange & Mysterious Death Of Chuck Morgan
Chuck had a secret tucked in his underwear. And beyond that, what happened to him over the course of 2 months back in the Spring of 1977 is something totally sensational and it doesn’t happen to regular folks…..It involves the mafia, Millions of dollars, a kidnapping, a drugging, an undercover agent, strange phone calls and cyphers and of course, a death.
24 min
57
Mystery in Vermont: The HAUNTING Disappearances...
What exactly is the deal with The Bennington Triangle? Are these odd occurrences and missing people happening completely independently and it’s just a coincidence that they happen in the same place. OR is there something else to it? A darker, even paranormal explanation that this area of Vermont is somehow responsible for causing bad things to happen?
25 min
58
The Most Unbelievable & Terrifying Murder Spree...
His name was Anthony Arkwright and chances are if you’re not from England then you probably havn’t even heard of him. But in the span of just a couple days he did a couple things so terrifying and messed up that I almost didn’t make this episode.
21 min
59
Snatched In The Night: Who Took Young Jaclyn, A...
Today we’re covering the mysterious circumstances under which Jaclyn Dowaliby vanished one evening, taken right from the comfort and safety of her bed and was never seen alive again.
25 min
60
Chicago Has A Serial Killer On The Loose
Since 2022 16 bodies in total have been discovered in various bodies of water there, mainly Lake Michigan but also in the Chicago river, and it’s prompted a lot of questions from the public as they try and grapple with the true nature behind these tragic deaths. And Many are fearing that perhaps a serial killer may be out there and police are failing to do connect the dots.
28 min
61
Strip Search Scam Alert: The Dangerous Game of ...
Today we’re headed to Mount Washington in Kentucky for the main story that blew this case wide open, but really these vicious calls happened all around the United States as one sick and twisted individual refined his ability to groom strangers in to do some bad things…things that were not just criminal but went so far beyond what even makes logical sense that they seam unreal.
25 min
62
The Zodiac Copycat: Did Americas Most Notorious...
Police in New York City in the early 90’s began finding victim who had been attacked at random AND then received cryptic messages that revolved around Zodiac signs – they thought that perhaps the Zodiac Killer had packed up and relocated and was now terrorizing the East Coast.
24 min
63
The Worst Crime Imaginable: 43 Years Later, Thi...
The real sinister stories pop up in otherwise safe towns, and are committed by friends, family members and those trusted in the community. Back in 1975 Marple Township In Pennsylvania was a wonderful place to raise a family and a great place for kids to play….. and one person, who walked among them was a predator who saw this as the perfect opportunity to catch his prey and get away with it.
25 min
64
Where Did He Go? The UNSETTLING Story Of Israel...
Israel Smith disappeared on March 10th of 08 without a trace at all…it was very strange for everyone in the community to say the least. To this day no hard evidence has been discovered to point to where he went or what happened to him…..But of course anyone close to the case has their theory and those vary greatly. No matter which one you pick, none of them make a whole lot of sense AND at the end of the day they are just theories.
23 min
65
The UNSOLVED Santa Rosa Hitchhiker Murders Has ...
7 known victims of the Santa Rosa Killer though there are suspected to be much more….we’re going to hear about who exactly Jim Mordacai was and look to connect the dots between him and this madman just as his family continues to do at this very moment with the assistance from the authorities.
24 min
66
A Truck Full Of Acid: Europe's Most Unsolved My...
Every once and while you come across an unsolved mystery so tragic and strange, that the possibilities about what could have actually transpired splinter off into various factions. Each one has a piece of the truth, but never does the whole story emerge….which is why the case of Juan Pedro Martinez has become one of the more bizarre disappearances in Europe’s recent history.
23 min
67
The Dnepropetrovsk Maniacs - The Boys Who Filme...
Born within just two months of one another back in the Spring of 1988, Viktor Sayenko, Igor Suprunyuk and Alexander Hanzha were close friends who all grew up together in Ukraines fourth largest city, Dnipro, which was formally known as Dnipropetrovsk up until 2016.
22 min
68
Demonic Possession By An 'Old, Burnt Man' - Arn...
This is “the Devil made me Do it” defense…meaning our killer claims to have gotten possessed by a demon…an old burnt up skinny man demon, who took over control of his body and then forced them to kill. It’s the only time ever that this defense has been attempted in United States history and whether or not it succeeded, well stick around and find out.
25 min
69
The Allagash Encounter: A True UFO Abduction Story
Today we’re headed to Maine which as you may know has been dubbed Vacationland and for good reason. As that’ exactly what our subjects headed there to do during one summer almost 50 years ago. Their story has been called the Allagash Abduction incident and it is perhaps one of the more famous stories of a first hand Alien encounter to ever occur in The United States.
25 min
70
Alaska Has The MOST Missing Persons Cases Of An...
To put in context, In Alaska since 1988, more than 16,000 people have dissappeared which is a huge number. For every 100,000 people, 164 of them have gone missing which is far higher than any other state by a long shot as the 49 states average out to around just 6 people missing per 100,000. Those figures aren’t skewed for effect for the sake of this episode, it’s a fact and so the question becomes….what exactly is going on in Alaska?
21 min
71
Final Frames: The Mysterious Disappearance & Fo...
Kris Kremers and Lisanne Froon were young university friends and roommates when they decided to take a well deserved trip over to Panama. It was of course supposed to be a fun time for the girls but it quickly turned into a fight for thier lives and when the details emerged about what they had gone through it was not only terrifying, but also led to a lot of speculation and questions, many of which are still unresolved to this day.
25 min
72
Staten Island's Nightmare: The Urban Legend Tha...
Today we’re diving deep into the legend of Cropsey…the boogyman for lack of a better term, that haunts the woods of Staten island. His story is one that everyone who lives there has heard…it varies a bit in details depending on who you hear it from but all the tales about Cropsey share the same base about an escaped mental patient who now hides in the woods and only comes out to prey on little children. But unlike many Urban legends, this one has a lot of hard evidence behind it.
26 min
73
Creepy Cold Case - 7 Year Old Disappeared From ...
Portland Oregon has a lot of True Crime stories to tell but one of them, in my mind, stands out above the rest. Because for one it revolves around the disappearance of a 7 year old kid who has yet to be found….And also because while it appears as though the person responsible was someone very close to him…at this point in the case, that’s all just speculation. Kyron Horman went missing one day from school back in 2010 and as we dug into the case, it became frustrating to see one dead end after another as well as several mistakes and lies come to light.
22 min
74
Sleepover Nightmare: The Terrifying Story of Po...
The story of Polly Klass is one that reached far and wide because it violated something that every single one of us values…And that’s the safety, comfort and fun of our own homes. Ultimately her case changed the face of law enforcement all across the United States and for good reason, because the man who did all this, never should have been allowed to be let out of prison as he was a clear danger to any community he stepped foot in. So let’s head over to Petaluma California and learn about the rarest of kidnappings that had a terrible outcome….This is the story of Polly Klaas.
27 min
75
Listen Now: Season 2 of PROOF
The second season of PROOF: Murder at the Warehouse takes Susan Simpson and Jacinda Davis to Manteca, CA where they reinvestigate the murder of 18-year-old Renee Ramos. On June 5, 2000, Ramos’ body was found buried under a pile of debris inside the shell of a new Home Depot building.
5 min