Every Town
Every Town has a dark side and in this podcast we bring you the most insane True Crime stories, many of which you've never even heard of. We give it to you straight with no fluff. Just scary true stories that will keep you up at night. Because the truth is, no matter how nice a place may appear on the surface, Every Town Has A Dark Side.
Hosted by: Andrew Fitzgerald
👀 Watch This Episode On Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/scarymysteries
👁 Check out our movie AN ANGRY BOY: https://www.anangryboy.com
💀 MERCH: https://scary-mysteries-merch.dashery.com
💀 Scary Mysteries SECRET VAULT: https://www.patreon.com/c/scarymysteries/collections
🎧 Our Other Podcast Scary Mysteries: https://open.spotify.com/show/3ZooEZMoZ421WdsOVJhVkT
👁 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/andrew.fitzg
👁 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@andrewfitzgerald
👁 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/scarymysteriesofficial
👁 X: https://x.com/ScaryMysteries1
🗣 Business Inquiries, questions and comments hit us up at scarymysteries1@gmail.com
1
The Most Brutal Unsolved Crime In Illinois Hist...
Today we’re checking out One of the Most Violent Unsolved Murders Illinois has ever seen. This is the case of The Derdeen Family Murders.
28 min
2
MICHIGAN'S Most Prolific Serial KILLER - The Su...
Today we have an interesting one that I know is going to stick with you for a long time. So let’s head over to Michigan and dig into the case of Carl Eugene Watts. A.K.A The Sunday Morning Slasher
28 min
3
VANISHED in Michigan - The Afternoon Paige Renk...
Today we have a strange cold case that very recently got flowing again after 35 years. So Let’s head over to Michigan and find out why and what exactly happened The Afternoon Paige Renkoski Disappeared.
26 min
4
A Vacation That Turned FATAL - The Death Valley...
Today, we’re heading deep into the California desert for a cautionary tale about isolation, miscalculation, and just how unforgiving nature can be. Let’s step into Death Valley and unravel the tragic mystery of the Death Valley Germans.
27 min
5
We’re Living In a DYSTOPIA and Most People Don'...
The machine keeps you scrolling! Today we’re going deep into the darkest corners of our shared reality. And this episode is truly terrifying because each and every one of us is affected by this horrible happening and the worst part is, everyone’s barley even noticing.
28 min
6
Wyoming’s Most Unsettling Unsolved Case: The St...
Today we’re headed out west for a strange one. This is Wyoming’s Most Unsettling Unsolved Case: The Strange Death Of Don Kemp.
28 min
7
The Shared PSYCHOTIC Break That Played Out in P...
One of the more insane stories you've never heard of comes from the Eriksson Twins, who shared a psychotic break and it was all caught on camera.
27 min
8
MONSTERS In America: What’s Real, What’s Not, a...
Today we’re taking a closer look what exactly cryptid encounters are. We’ll look at the science, the misidentifications and of course the handful of sightings that still don’t make a lick of sense. This is Monsters in America: The Truth Behind Cryptid Encounters
28 min
9
The Night Ryan Vanished - British Columbia’s Un...
Today we’re heading up north to Canada to explore a missing persons case that doesn’t sit right for multiple reason reasons. So let’s head over to British Columbia now and check out the mystery behind Ryan Shtuka - A Vanishing at Sun Peaks
28 min
10
Every Town Has A Dark Side - BEST of 2025
Today we’re wrapping up 2025 in style and sharing with you 3 of our favorite Every Town episodes PLUS 3 exclusive stories coming straight from our Patreon vault! So there’s a little something new for everyone.
97 min
11
New Jersey’s DARKEST Unsolved Mystery - What Re...
Today we’re taking a look at a case that no matter what angle you take, it doesn’t totally add up. It’s a mystery and a tragedy and for years, the Tiffany’s family has been fighting to find answers.
29 min
12
OHIO’S Most Disturbing Unsolved Death
Today we’re digging into one of Ohio’s strangest mysteries, a case that’s haunted investigators and true crime fans for over four decades.
28 min
13
The Boy Scout Serial Killer - The Crimes of Joh...
Today we’re checking out a serial killer you’ve probably never even heard of. A guy whose motivation wasn’t in the end result but in the process itself.
27 min
14
The DEVIL In New York - How a Cop Became a Demo...
This is The Devil in New York - How a Cop Became a Demon Hunter.
31 min
15
The PORTSMOUTH Beauty School Murders
Today we’re checking out the story of 2 girls who attended the same school in NH and unfortunately met the same dark end. So let’s dig in to the Portsmouth Beauty School Murders.
26 min
16
Is A Serial Killer On The Prowl In Houstons Bay...
Today we’re going to follow the current on Texas’s most tragic story that’s currently unfolding. To see whether Houston’s water is just taking what it always takes, or if something else is pulling people under.
29 min
17
UFO’s: How The PENTAGON Created America's Great...
It looks like we the people didn’t create all these alien and UFO stories in the way we think. They’ve been fed to us. And we swallowed them, hook, line, and sinker.
27 min
18
Listen Now: American History Tellers | The Mayf...
Listen to American History Tellers: Wondery.fm/AHT_ET
3 min
19
TIME SLIPS: Real Phenomenon or Perfect Illusion?
Today we’re chasing time slips: Is something out there glitching, or are we? -To Get 15% off your next gift, go to UNCOMMONGOODS.com/EVERYTOWN
31 min
20
The Night Halloween Died: The Shauna Howe Case
An event so disturbing and visceral that for sixteen years, Halloween was erased from Oil City, PA.
27 min
21
Halloween’s Dark Reality: The Night That Enable...
Tonight isn’t about ghosts, goblins or monsters, it’s about what a costume lets ordinary people get away with. Four true stories, one night that keeps inviting bad choices. So let’s head around the country and check out Halloween’s Dark Reality: The Night That Enables Evil.
29 min
22
The Dark Side of Airbnb: Terrifying Vacation Re...
Today we’re talking about Airbnb, VRBO and the dark side of the whole short term rental industry as a whole. This is The Dark Side of Airbnb: Terrifying Vacation Rental Stories
28 min
23
The White House Farm Massacre: Betrayal, Murder...
Today this isn’t just a case of murder — it’s a puzzle with missing pieces, contradictions, and questions that refuse to go away.
32 min
24
Maryland’s Most Shocking Murder: The Lululemon ...
Today, we’re diving into the unsettling crime cover-up that happened at a Lululemon in Maryland.
27 min
25
A Killing That Went Live - The Viral Crime That...
Today, we’re going inside a case so disturbing, so public, that the deeper you dig, the harder it is to understand how it could have happened at all.
30 min