Eye for an Eye
A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"
101
Swipe Right... with Caution- Episode 45- Grace ...
Grace Millane was a recent college graduate who was backpacking through New Zealand in December of 2018, when her whole world was shattered.
35 min
102
Just Hold On, We’re Going Holmes- Episode 44- J...
Fans of the Batman franchise had no idea the horror they were walking into when they went to the midnight screening of “The Dark Knight Rises” on July 20, 2012.
103 min
103
A True Monster- Episode 43- Chris Watts
On August 13th, 2018, expectant mother Shan’ann Watts and her daughters Bella and Celeste were reported missing from their home in Frederick, Colorado. No-one could have ever imagined where Shan'ann and her two daughters would be found...
60 min
104
Calling All Web Sleuths- Episode 42- Natalie Bo...
51 min
105
Elisa Lam- Episode 1- A Blind Eye
First Look at Patreon Exclusive Series- A Blind Eye
68 min
106
It is the MASH, the Monster Mashup- Bonus Hallo...
63 min
107
Slender Man- 8- Streamin n' Screamin
This weeks episode? Get ready to head to the forest to meet up with the faceless face himself, Mr. Slender Man.
37 min
108
Horrors in Happy Valley- Episode 41- Jerry Sand...
Join Lisa, Matt, and Special Guest John Ryan as they wrap up season one and unravel the deepest rooted scandal in the history of the NCAA.
154 min
109
The Girl in the Box- Episode 40- Colleen Stan
Imagine being locked in a coffin-like box for 23 hours a day for seven years...
66 min
110
GirlMeatHunter- Episode 39- Gilberto Valle
By day Gilberto Valle was a family man, a loving dad and husband, and a devoted member of the NYPD- however, when night time rolled around - Gilberto would log into his computer and become something much more nefarious. He would become "Girlmeathunter"
62 min
111
Knock Knock- Episode 38- Danny LaPlante
Do you believe in ghosts? Do you believe if you follow the proper channels you can contact your deceased loved ones?
57 min
112
Have you ever had an expired chip in an unopene...
Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa and Matt do...at least once a day.
42 min
113
Steak, Lobster Tail, Apple Pie, Vanilla Ice Cre...
With a last meal of steak, lobster tail, apple pie, vanilla ice cream and 7-Up, followed by a 48-hour fast while watching The Lord of the Rings Trilogy, Ronnie Lee Gardner seemingly was at peace with his fate..
78 min
114
Get Out - MINI SERIES EPI 7- Streamin n' Screamin
This weeks episode? Get ready to go into the sunken place with us as we go over all things Get Out. How did this horror movie receive an unheard-for-the-genre 99% on Rotten Tomatoes?
48 min
115
Evil Genius Unveiled Part Two- Episode 36-Brian...
On the afternoon of August 28, 2003, a local pizza delivery man, Brian Wells, set out to deliver two large pizzas. What started as a typical delivery, ended up becoming one of the most shocking criminal cases that the town of Erie PA has ever seen.
73 min
116
Fourteen Servings- Minisode 15- WTH3
Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?"
6 min
117
Evil Genius Unveiled Part One- Episode 35-Brian...
What started as a typical pizza delivery, ended up becoming one of the most shocking criminal cases that the town of Erie, PA has ever seen.
93 min
118
Shark Week- Minisode 14- WTH3
Ever read about a crime or news headline and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?"
12 min
119
Find that CHIPPER!- Episode 34- Helle Crafts
When a beloved flight attendant disappears without a trace, one question remained- What happened to Helle Crafts?
89 min
120
From Star Athlete to Convicted Murderer- Episod...
Join Lisa and Matt as they recount the tragic rise and fall of Aaron Hernandez. What happened to Odin Lloyd and who was responsible? Could CTE have played a key role in this tragic tale? And most of all...did the punishment fit the crime?
74 min
121
Insidious - MINI SERIES EPI 6- Streamin n' Scre...
This weeks episode? All about Insidious (the first one). Did you know James Wan's dog make a cameo? Find out what movie made the main cast of Insidious have deja vu.
34 min
122
The Shining - MINI SERIES EPI 5- Streamin n' Sc...
Find out what he did to make sure Jack Nicholson was constantly irritated (hint it involves Lisa's favorite food) and that some members of the cast had no idea they were filming a horror movie.
40 min
123
Hooters with a Side of Homicide- Episode 32- Er...
When gasoline meets a lit match, fire is imminent. That’s the dynamic Erika and BJ Sifrit had. The question wasn't whether or not these two committed a heinous crime, but more so, which one pulled the trigger?
43 min
124
Dancing Queen- Minisode 13- WTH3
Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?"
40 min
125
Banana Basher- Episode 31- Eric Smith
86 min