Eye for an Eye
A look into the interdiction and sentencing of some of history's most infamous killers and criminals. Delve into the cases that have haunted headlines for decades and those left in the shadows of the justice system. Listen closely as you may find a new perspective on justice that, at times, you may be surprised you agree with. Join your hosts Lisa, Matt, and Jules while they answer the age old question, "Does the punishment fit the crime?"
26
Henthorn House of Horror- Episode 93- Harold He...
Could it be mere coincidence that two people Harold claimed to love till death do they part- died... ?
46 min
27
Night Skating in Culver City- Episode 92- Harve...
According to Matt, everyone is one or two degrees of separation from a murderer. Today we put that theory to the test.
101 min
28
Terror in Green River- Episode 91- Gary Ridgway
As detectives closed in with the help of another infamous mad man, the Pacific North Wests' most prolific serial killer was broken down piece by piece until he became his only available defense witness...
52 min
29
Twenty Times Too Many, What Really Happened to ...
o this day, law enforcement cannot explain how this ruling came to be given the plethora of evidence pointing the other way. We will do our best to fill in the numerous holes in the investigation and discuss once and for all- what really happened to Ellen Greensberg?
50 min
30
All Over a Game of Yahtzee... -Episode 89- Tama...
fter a Christmas meal with her three sons, Tamara Lee Mason suggested the four of them play a game of Yahtzee to close out the nights festivities. Little did she know, this game night suggestion would set off an unimaginable train of events.
66 min
31
Milwaukee’s Madman- Episode 88- Part Two- Jeffr...
This is part two of Eye for an Eyes look at the infamous necrophile and cannibal- Jeffrey Dahmer.
65 min
32
Milwaukee’s Madman- Episode 87- Part One- Jeff...
Fasten your seatbelts and grab your puke buckets because todays we're talking a monster who's name should've been buried with him long ago- Jeffrey Dahmer.
47 min
33
A Wild Web of What-ifs- Episode 86- Jodi Arias
We will do our best to unweave the web of lies that were intended to cover up a vicious murder... Was Jodi the only spared victim of a vicious attack on her lover or would a camera found in a washing machine tell a very different story...
68 min
34
Theories, Questions, and What We Know So Far- ...
On November 13, 2022 - a quadruple homicide of four beautiful college students would shake not only the small town of Moscow, Idaho- but the world.
111 min
35
Through the Looking Glass - Interview with a La...
Join Matt, Lisa, and Jules as we conduct our most gripping interview yet, with one of our most unique guest stars to grace our show yet.
105 min
36
He Dug Himself A 12.7 Year Sentence- Bonus Epis...
We're back with another bonus episode. Since we recorded the episode on the infamous Josh Duggar of 19 Kids and Counting fame, he has been sentenced for his crimes. Join Matt, Jules and Lisa as we break down his sentence and ultimately decide if an Eye for an Eye was finally met.
20 min
37
Help! I Need a Husband- Episode 41- WTH3
Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa Jules and Matt do...at least once a day.
11 min
38
We Must Keep This Conversation Going- Bonus Epi...
The United States is not the only country with mental illness, domestic violence, or hate-fueled ideologies, but our gun homicide rate is 26 times higher than other high-income countries. It's time to confront why.
46 min
39
You Didn't Yell Yahtzee!!- Episode 40- WTH3
Games can bring the best out of people...or they can bring the absolute worst out of people...
8 min
40
My Son, The Killer- Bonus Episode- Luka Magnott...
While we continue preparing for the launch of season three of Eye for an Eye Podcast, we wanted to discuss a memoir Eye for an Eye was sent a few years ago...think of this as a bonus book club of sorts.
42 min
41
No Cuddles From Duddles- Episode 39- WTH3
You wake up from a drunken soiree. You hear what sounds like a train horn coming from your bedroom. What would you do? Well, Benjamin Duddles decided he needed backup...
10 min
42
What Really Happened to Elisa Lam?- Bonus Episo...
With the Netflix docuseries "Crime Scene: The Vanishing at the Cecil Hotel" bringing the case back into the spot light-it only made sense to revaluate the case that mystified millions. Join Jules and Lisa as we go back over the spine chilling case of Elisa Lam
21 min
43
I Can't Believe...It Was Actually Butter- Episo...
Some people like to put butter on their toast...some like to use butter as a weapon...
12 min
44
Cruelty from Casey; Justice for Caylee? - Episo...
Caylee’s life was cut short, and as the world seeks Justice, Eye for an Eye asks if what happened to Casey was the epitome of injustice-- ..and what ultimately happened to little Caylee Anthony?
72 min
45
McNugget McMeltdown- Episode 37- WTH3
Ever read about a crime and think to yourself, "What the hell happened here?" Well...Lisa Jules and Matt do...at least once a day.
13 min
46
Oh No Poconos: the Ben Amato Story- Episode 82-...
The Pocono Mountains are a peaceful place. A place where people go to relax, enjoy the small town vibes and scenic mountains. That peace was ripped away from Ben Amato by his girlfriend, Cheryl.
45 min
47
Disappearing DB- Episode 81- DB Cooper and The ...
Join Matt, Lisa, and Jules as they investigate one of US History’s most notorious whodunnits. DB Cooper hijacked a plane, got out before it landed, and avoided the authorities on the ground to remain at large to this day.
44 min
48
Call 911, Cause We Need To TACObout It!!!!- Epi...
Join Lisa and Jules as we discuss how one man wanted to do the responsible thing, but also really really really wanted some tacos.
11 min
49
What Was Really Wrong With Aunt Diane?- Episode...
Join Lisa and Jules as they discuss the timeline leading up to the horrific crash that changed so many lives forever. We'll discuss whether we think Daniel Schuler truly believes his account of events or if we think he is just trying to protect his late wife. We want to know- what was really wrong with Aunt Diane?
73 min
50
True Love or Taken Advantage Of- Episode 79- Ma...
Teachers are trusted adults in the community. We trust them to teach, care for and nurture our youth. But what happens when that nurturing crosses the line? Far beyond the line...
58 min