Defense Diaries

Original true crime podcast. Join your host, criminal defense attorney Bob Motta for:

season one: The Gacy Tapes- We enter the twisted mind of serial killer John Wayne Gacy through the use of 15 hours of never before heard, pre-trial interviews with Gacy and his attorneys, as they prepare for the trial of the century.

Season two: Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr Anthony Garcia -join Bob as he, his wife Alison, and father Bob Sr. are hired to represent Dr. Anthony Garcia.

Season three: Bob and Ali cover more current events and headline making stories as Defense Diaries presents: The Docket

Season four: The Docket: Strings Attached: Idaho v. Lori Vallow-Daybell

Season five: The Docket: Idaho 4- Bob and Ali discuss the tragic case of The Idaho 4

Season six: The Docket: Delphi- Bob and Ali discuss the ever tragic and horrific murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German. They also breakdown every aspect of this befuddling case.

Season seven : Steven Avery: Innocent or Guilty: A Full Case Analysis- Bob and Ali give an unbiased presentation and breakdown of all the evidence in this case.

True Crime
51
The Docket ep. 804: Massachusetts v. Karen Read...
Bob and Ali continue their coverage of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Karen Read. Read is accused of killing her boyfriend John O'Keefe by running over him with her vehicle and leaving him for dead. The defense has an entirely different theory as to what happened. Have some of the twists and turns of this case explained from a legal perspective.
65 min
52
The Docket ep. 803: Massachusetts v. Karen Read...
Alongside Jay Shaming @theshamingofjay and Jack from @neveratruerword we continue to evaluate the testimony of Jennifer Mccabe. Mccabe is a witness for the prosecution in the case The Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Karen Read. Read is accused of killing John O'Keefe.
124 min
53
he Docket EP. 802: Massachusetts v. Karen Read:...
Bob is joined by Jay Shaming @theshamingofjay and Jack from @neveratruerword to break down and analyze the testimony of Jenn McCabe. She is a state's witness in the trial Massachusetts v. Karen Read for the death of John O'Keefe. Audio taken from a YouTube Live episode.
128 min
54
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia e...
We continue to dive into the interview with the state's star witness Cecelia Hofmann and the Indiana State Police. They are focused on a visit from the defense team's P.I. and a phone call between Hofmann, Alison, and aforementioned P.I.
55 min
55
The Docket Ep. 801: Massachusetts v. Karen Read...
Bob and Ali begin discussing the Karen Read case. Audio taken from youtube live with a preface by Bob.
99 min
56
The Docket Ep. 628: The Delphi Murders pt. 28
Bob and Ali Motta continue their coverage of the State of Indiana v Richard Allen. Allen stands accused of the murders of Liberty German and Abigail Williams. Audio for this episode is from a youtube live video on 4-23-2024.
95 min
57
The Docket ep. 627: The Delphi Murders pt 27
Bob and Ali continue in depth coverage of the case of Indiana v. Richard Allen. Audio taken from YT live on
67 min
58
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr Anthony Garcia Ep...
After Cecelia Hoffman was visited by a P.I. she notifies OMD. In turn OPD contacts Indiana State Police asking them to take a statement from Hoffman in regard to the nature of the interview and how she answered the questions she was asked.
55 min
59
The Docket ep.626: The Delphi Murders pt. 26
Bob and Ali continue coverage of the case of Indiana v. Richard Allen. Bob was boots on the ground for the hearing on 3.18.24. Hear him discuss what happened, within. Audio taken from youtube live 3.18.24
62 min
60
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia e...
We find ourdelves back in an Omaha court room. We'll hear from the defense's expert witness and how he views the evidence. Brenda Beadle doesn't seem too fond of his expert testimony. Honestly, she doesn't seem to care much for him at all. To say the feeling is mutual, may not do it justice
81 min
61
The Docket ep. 625: The Delphi Murders pt. 25
We continue our coverage into the State of Indiana vs, Richard Allen. He's been charged for the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German. In this episode we will go over the pleadings filed by Brad Rozzi and Andrew Baldwin for the defense and those filed by Nick McLeland for the state. Judge Francis Gull presides. Audio from YT live on 3.15.24
74 min
62
The Docket ep. 624: The Delphi Murder pt. 24
Andrew Baldwin and Brad Rozzi, aka defense counsel for Richard Allen, have filed an 18 page motion to compel. Will Judge Gull actually have a hearing? Hear this motion in it's entirety on this episode of The Docket.
146 min
63
The Docket ep. 623: The Delphi Murders pt. 23
New Motions have been Filed in the State of Indiana v. Richard Allen case, Allen stands accused of the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German. If Judge Gull decides to have a hearing for these motions they will be argued by Nick McLeland for the state and Andrew Baldwin and Brad Rozzi for defense.
86 min
64
The Docket ep. 622: The Delphi Murders pt. 22
Attorneys Brad Rozzi and Andrew Baldwin file a motion for a speedy trial demand on behalf of their client Richard Allen. Allen stands accused of the murders of Liberty German and Abigail Williams. Judge Gull will have to set a new trial date soon.
50 min
65
The Docket Ep. 621: The Delphi Murders pt. 21
It seems as though there isn't a day that passes where nothing happens in the case of The state of Indiana v. Richard Allen, Today was no exception. Listen in as Bob continues goes through Judge Gull's denial of several of the defense's motions. Audio from youtube live 02/21/24
46 min
66
The Docket ep. 620: The Delphi Murders pt. 20
Join Bob Motta as he continues the in depth coverage of the State of Indiana v. Richard Allen. Allen is charged with the murders of Liberty German and Abigail Williams. This episode Bob will go through Allen's defense attorney's ( Andrew Baldwin and Brad Rozzi's) response to the states motion to compel discovery. We'll also discuss some of the recent decisions/rulings made by Judge Fran C. Gull
45 min
67
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia E...
A star state witness may be second guessing her own statement. Lets hear what she has to say this time and what potential impact it could have on this case, and potentially elsewhere
63 min
68
The Docket ep. 619: The Delphi Murders pt. 19
The Supreme court of Indiana explain their recent rulings. How they will effect defense attorneys Brad Rozzi and Andrew Baldwin, and their client Richard Allen. The quest for justice for Liberty German and Abigail Williams continues.
77 min
69
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia E...
Its time for Ali to cross examine the states witness, The defense has filed a motion to sever, in an attempt to separate the charges against Anthony Garcia.
75 min
70
The Docket Ep. 618: The Delphi Murders pt. 18
Bob and Ali continue to discuss the Delphi Murders. Richard Allen has been charged with two counts of murder for the killings of Abigail Williams and Liberty German.
108 min
71
The Docket Ep.617: The Delphi Murders pt. 17
Bob and Ali are joined by Indiana defense attorney Cara Wieneke to discuss the recent events in the Delphi case. Sponsor for this episode is Nomnom for 50% off of your first order go to www.nom.com/DD
109 min
72
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia e...
The trial rages on. The state calls their expert witness and the defense cross examines.
66 min
73
The Docket Ep. 616: The Delphi Murders pt.16
Huge news from the Indiana Supreme Court. Audio from this episode taken from a Defense Diaries YT live that aired on 01-18-24.
32 min
74
Tunnel Vision: Nebraska v. Dr. Anthony Garcia E...
The extensive media coverage in and around Omaha is, at this point, a real issue for the defense. The decision is made to poll the general public and the results are revealed within. Also, a motion for severance is filed.
47 min
75
The Docket Ep. 615: The Delphi Murders pt.15
Bob and Ali continue to discuss the Delphi murders. Adio takenm from YT live on 1.12.24
39 min