Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast

Moms and Mysteries is a true crime podcast hosted by Mandy and Melissa, two friends who deep dive into a new case each week. Conversational in tone and heavy on the levity, you’ll enjoy their original takes on both the well-known, and those lesser heard of true crime stories.

True Crime
Society & Culture
351
Jenelle Potter
Happy Holidays, friends! Get ready for a shocker of a show this week. Join Melissa and Mandy as they discuss the murder of Billie Jean Hayworth and Billy Payne, two parents, killed over a social media un-friending. This story has so many twists and...
50 min
352
Justin Michael
This week the ladies are Manksless and back to your regularly scheduled programming. Join the ladies as they discuss the devastating murder of Justin Michael. Justin was a friend, son and fiancé. Who would want to kill Justin just feet away from him...
47 min
353
Interview With Dateline's Josh Mankiewicz
  What do you get when you mix Dateline’s Josh “The Manks” Mankiewicz and the ladies of Moms and Murder together? The best show ever! Join us this week as we talk behind the scenes of Dateline, why Manks believes the world is fascinated...
72 min
354
The Bling Ring
20 Episodes in and we decided to skip the homicide and settle in for a good old fashion tale of Hollywood’s Bling Ring. The ladies discuss one of the greatest clips in all of Reality Show history (even Mandy agrees!) and Melissa plays a game of...
45 min
355
Vampire Cult Killers
Vampire Cult When you think of Moms and Murder the first thing you think is “Vampire Cult Killers”, right? Well, this week you will. Join the Moms as they discuss the NOT TOTALLY FLORIDA, Vampire Cult, why it matters who you hang out with, and...
61 min
356
Darlene Gentry
Today we’re discussing the unjustifiable death of devoted husband and father, Keith Gentry, and we will examine how his wife, Darlene found herself at the center of the investigation. Mandy goes on a weird rant about organ donation and offers up...
60 min
357
Samira Frasch
This week the patron’s have spoken! Our friend’s over on the old patreon page voted for this week’s episode and they have chosen Melissa’s hometown story! Join the ladies as they discuss the puzzling death of Samira Frasch and find out whether...
57 min
358
Cindy Song
Happy almost November 1st (or just Happy Halloween if you are not weird like Melissa and aren’t terrified of Halloween). This week Mandy forced Melissa to talk about a Halloween case, but in a true portrayal of friendship, she did not choose...
51 min
359
Podcast Extravaganza
This week Melissa and Mandy got lazy. Real, real lazy. So lazy in fact that they invited some of their friends to do all of the research for them! Join them for the celebration of their 15th show (that’s a thing, they promise). They also have a...
144 min
360
Jasmine Fiore
Jasmine Fiore was a small town girl with dreams of living a big city life. After meeting Ryan Jenkins she thought she had found her prince, but she could not have been more wrong. Listen in as we discuss the rise and fall of reality star Ryan Jenkins...
57 min
361
Clara Harris
Clara Harris was a Mom, Wife, Dentist, and the subject of the most terrible Lifetime Movie of all time. Today the ladies talk the death of David Harris at the hands of his wife, Clara. Was it a cold-blooded murder, a crime of passion, or a terrible...
52 min
362
The Clear Lake Murders
*This week’s episode was recorded prior to the massacre in Las Vegas. In this episode we discuss “The Clear Lake Murders”, and we understand if it’s not something you are ready to hear about after the events of the week.*   Another day,...
56 min
363
Uloma Curry-Walker
This week we are delving into the senseless murder of everyone’s hero, William Walker. We will unravel the details of this poorly planned murder plot, tell you how criminals keep ruining food for us, and reiterate why you should always keep the...
40 min
364
Kelley Clayton
It’s our 10th episode! This week we discuss the untimely death of the lovely, Kelley Clayton. We’ll go through what happened the night of her death and talk about why, if you’re going to be dumb enough to commit a crime, at least be smart...
57 min
365
Frederic Bourdin
This week, the ears have it! Join Melissa with her very special guest, her sister Megan, as they break down the strange but true story of Frederic Bourdin. Find out whether or not you can smoke in Spain, how to get a quick group home tattoo, and stick...
48 min
366
Sherri Rasmussen
Put on your shoulder pads and tease your hair to the heavens and join us this week as we discuss the peculiar murder of Sherri Rasmussen. We’ll look at the timelines of events surrounding Sherri’s last days, and discuss why the husband very well...
54 min
367
Rebecca Zahau
This week we are diving deep into the mysterious death of Rebecca Zahau. Was it murder? Was it suicide? Are Tug Boat Captains a real thing? We will discuss all of this and more on this week’s episode of Moms and Murder. You will learn why you should...
57 min
368
Anthony Curcio
Join us this week as we discuss our favorite bank heist, and story of Anthony Curcio. This robbery is one of the most elaborate and creative that you’ll ever hear and Anthony may have gotten away with it if it wasn’t for the keen eye of an...
48 min
369
Diane Schuler
This week we discuss the 2009 Taconic State Parkway crash of Diane Schuler and the seven victims of this terrible wreck : Emma Hance (8), Alyson Hance (7), Kate Hance (5), Erin Schuler (2), Michael Bastardi (81 ), Daniel Longo (74), and Guy Bastardi...
58 min
370
Erin Caffey
As the late, great, Aaliyah once said “Age ain’t nothing but a number”… that is, unless you’re a 20 year old high school senior dating your 16 year old classmate who has decided to have her entire family killed and needs your help! Then the...
52 min
371
Todd Kohlhepp
Todd Kohlhepp: America’s Least Favorite Amazon Reviewer. This week we move out of Florida into the land of South Carolina…well, sort of. We are discussing the bewildering case of Todd Kohlhepp, who was either a “good boy” or American serial...
48 min
372
BONUS - Mini Episode: Dalia Dippolito
First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes… a hired hit man?! Join us in our first Bonus-Mini Episode as we do a quick breakdown on the love affair of Mike and Dalia Dippolito and her lover/police informant. This case just came to a...
19 min
373
Casey Anthony (Part 2)
It’s #truecrimetuesday, and that means it’s part 2 of the Casey Anthony saga, now with 50% less of Melissa and Mandy saying “By all accounts”, but even more Google shout-outs! Find out what happens in court, and where Casey is now (Hint- she...
46 min
374
Casey Anthony (Part 1)
It’s our inaugural podcast! Join us as we breakdown the Curious Case of Casey Anthony on this week’s Moms and Murder podcast. Learn about the key players, why it’s important to only get tattoos in the languages you speak, and why we are both...
56 min